Police and singers clash for a third day in a row

2013-07-27T05:30:00Z Police and singers clash for a third day in a rowMATTHEW DeFOUR | Wisconsin State Journal | mdefour@madison.com | 608-252-6144 La Crosse Tribune

Neither side in a Capitol showdown between protest singers and police backed down Friday as a third day of arrests unfolded.

And another clash is looming Monday when the singers vow to return to the rotunda for more anti-Gov. Scott Walker songs while a pro-Walker group says it will lawfully occupy the space with a permit to sing patriotic tunes.

“They have commandeered this space, and the fact is, to get my song in edgewise, I’ve got to get a permit,” said David Blaska, a conservative columnist and former county supervisor who is organizing the group he calls the “We’ve Got a Permit” singers.

At issue is whether the Solidarity Singalong needs a permit to protest in the Capitol rotunda when more than 20 members are present.

On Friday, a permit for the space was taken out for 12-12:45 p.m. to be used for a wedding. The couple instead held the ceremony outside as singers and spectators gathered in the rotunda, according to Department of Administration spokeswoman Stephanie Marquis.

Singers say they’re entitled to protest in song without a permit under the First Amendment and state Constitution.

A state policy requires groups to get a permit to demonstrate in the Capitol or use space for other purposes, such as weddings.

The state originally required the permit for groups of four or more. But a federal judge this month issued a preliminary injunction, saying groups of 20 or fewer don’t need one. Judge William Conley let stand other elements of the permitting policy.

On Friday, police arrested 17 people and gave them $200.50 no-permit citations, Marquis said. Another 14 people were captured on video and will receive no-permit citations in the mail, she said.

About 50 citations were issued Wednesday and Thursday.

Friday also marked the first time during the recent dust-up that police began ticketing people gathered along the first-floor balcony above the rotunda floor.

Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald’s office sent a note to legislative offices warning staff not to congregate along the balcony during the protests.

“If you are in the vicinity of the illegal demonstrations that have been taking place over the noon hour in the rotunda, you will be considered part of the protests and are subject to being ticketed,” the message said.

Joe Meiller, a Madison Metro bus driver who brought his two sons to watch the singalong Friday from the balcony, was upset that he was asked to leave by Capitol police.

“We didn’t sing or clap once,” Meiller said. “If I observe a bank robbery nearby, am I a participant because I was nearby?”

Before issuing citations, Capitol Police set up a sandwich board alerting visitors that there was a scheduled wedding at noon and asking them to respect the permit held by a member of the wedding party.

Some singers went outside, but about 200 people — a mix of singers, reporters and observers — crowded the rotunda and balcony.

Marquis said in an emailed statement later Friday that the wedding was held outside the Capitol. She said it was to be held in the rotunda in the event of inclement weather but that the wedding party “made a decision to get married outside in the rain.” It’s unclear exactly when the wedding took place and under what conditions.

The noontime singalong has been taking place almost daily for more than two years and typically is held outside on Fridays during warm weather. Friday’s skies were gray with occasional rain.

Marquis said Capitol Police have already stated they would approve a permit if the singers applied for one.

“The permit is free and the group could continue to say and sing the same things they are today,” she said in a statement.

Protesters vowed to return Monday. That’s when Blaska will lead his group in singing “America the Beautiful” and “God Bless America.”

He did something similar in 2011, and the singers went outside.

Copyright 2015 La Crosse Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(11) Comments

  1. FUBAR
    Report Abuse
    FUBAR - July 27, 2013 11:37 am
    Sure, a Liberals keep screaming about their 1st amendment rights but, at the same time they would love to take away our 2nd amendment rights. Liberals believe the only rights that matter are the ones they exercise.
  2. Mac
    Report Abuse
    Mac - July 26, 2013 11:54 pm
    They could protest outside just as easily, but their main intent is to disrupt business at the capitol, hence the need for permits to keep things orderly and less disruptful. Head on out to the National Mall or the White House sidewalk with your protest and see how far you get without a permit.
  3. 668 The Neighbor of the Beast
    Report Abuse
    668 The Neighbor of the Beast - July 26, 2013 10:47 pm

    LoOnEy liberals ... it's a state capital building, not the walls of Jericho.
  4. Mr Wizard
    Report Abuse
    Mr Wizard - July 26, 2013 8:42 pm
    That's the problem. People who have the opposite opinion have jobs.
  5. RemoteEmployee
    Report Abuse
    RemoteEmployee - July 26, 2013 7:59 pm
    Everyone should travel to Madison and sing their hearts out!
  6. RemoteEmployee
    Report Abuse
    RemoteEmployee - July 26, 2013 7:35 pm
    Waiting for the Spark: Your post sounds threatening: Wondering where people live? People get to communicate; It is their right.
  7. RemoteEmployee
    Report Abuse
    RemoteEmployee - July 26, 2013 7:30 pm
    How about standing up for your 1st Amendment rights, Jessica?
  8. RemoteEmployee
    Report Abuse
    RemoteEmployee - July 26, 2013 7:29 pm
    Agree 100% with you Nap. These folks have no idea of the slippery slope they are traveling. It is very sad.
  9. RemoteEmployee
    Report Abuse
    RemoteEmployee - July 26, 2013 7:26 pm
    How do you say, First Amendment Rights?. The Southern states tried the same kind of strategy with Voting Rights. People get to say, or sing, anything they want to, (unless it is a crowded theater, yelling "fire"). This is a gross injustice. Scott is getting paid HUGE from the Koch brothers.
  10. Jessica
    Report Abuse
    Jessica - July 26, 2013 4:49 pm
    How about getting a permit. Other groups have. Or maybe you could split up into groups of 19 and sing different songs.
  11. Napoleon
    Report Abuse
    Napoleon - July 26, 2013 2:19 pm
    Vladimir Putin has got to be grinning from ear to ear!

    Republicans: "We stand for violence, repression and oligarchy! We stand as one with Scottimir Putin!"

    Don't vote for these GOP thugs! They're bad people!

    "Putin's Russia"


    "Russian journalist dies after beating in police custody"

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick