the ethical life

Richard Kyte: Empathy, sincerity go further than you think

2013-04-07T00:45:00Z 2013-06-27T10:03:45Z Richard Kyte: Empathy, sincerity go further than you thinkBy Richard Kyte | La Crosse La Crosse Tribune
April 07, 2013 12:45 am  • 

I was looking to rent a power washer, and ended up finding a small shop in a block of mostly empty storefronts in downtown Memphis, Tenn. The owner was one of those characters who is hard to forget.

He had been robbed several times at gunpoint, and his skull was fractured earlier in the year by a young man wielding an iron pipe. But what really worried him was the legal system. “I can’t afford the insurance that the big chain stores carry,” he said. “I’m just waiting for the day when a lawsuit shuts me down.”

He went on to tell stories of customers determined to injure themselves with his equipment, like the guy who leaned an extension ladder upside down against his house and fell 10 feet when he stepped onto the upper section of the ladder. He did that three times before coming back to the shop. “There’s something wrong with this damn ladder!” he shouted.

“Every time somebody rents a piece of equipment, I go through how to use it. But most people don’t pay attention or they do dumb things I would never even think of. Just ain’t no cure for stupid,” the shop owner concluded.

When things go wrong, our tendency is to create rules to prevent them from happening again. Then we hire experts to remind us what the rules are, how to interpret them and how to protect ourselves from those who want to use the rules against us. We have lots of rules about how to use the rules.

One of the rules about rules is this: When somebody is injured, never say “I’m sorry” — it could be used against you in court.

Two Wisconsin legislators have introduced a bill to allow doctors to apologize to patients without fearing that the statement could be used against them in a lawsuit. The Wisconsin Medical Society and the Wisconsin Hospital Association support the bill; the Wisconsin Association for Justice (representing trial lawyers) opposes it.

What I have read of arguments on both sides seems fundamentally misguided. What bothers me about the debate is the assumption that whenever something goes wrong, doctors and patients must necessarily become adversaries. It’s an assumption in direct contradiction to the ethos of health care. It erodes the trust and confidence of the patient and undermines the morale of the health care worker.

Regardless of whether the bill passes, it doesn’t have to be that way.

When Ken Melrose was CEO of Toro, he changed the way the company responded to customers injured by their products. Lawn mowers and snow blowers are inherently dangerous. No matter how safe Toro made its machines, some people still got injured. The challenge was how to respond.

Instead of seeking to change liability laws, the company developed something called “Alternate Dispute Resolution.” Whenever someone was injured using one of its products, regardless of whether the company thought it might be at fault, a team was sent to investigate and — this is the crucial part — express remorse.

Toro went from an average of 100 lawsuits a year, with half of them ending up in court, to settling two-thirds of their cases in the home and using a mediator for the rest. In the first 15 years of the program, only one injury case went to court.  

Laws designed to protect consumers can sometimes cause even more harm by turning people who want to do the right thing into the enemy. But as the Toro example shows, we don’t necessarily have to change the laws before we change our behavior.

People do stupid things, and sometimes those stupid things have terrible consequences. Most people understand that and are willing to make allowances, but only if goodwill and sincerity are evident at the outset.

The shop owner in Memphis could take heart from Toro’s example. You don’t have to be a large company to afford good customer service, and that turns out to be the best protection against lawsuits.

We shape our relationships by the conversations we have. And no healthy relationship can survive without the words, “I’m sorry.”

The Ethical Life is a series of reflections on the ways ethical thinking influences our actions, emotions and relationships. Richard Kyte is the director of the D.B. Reinhart Institute for Ethics in Leadership at Viterbo University.

Copyright 2015 La Crosse Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(9) Comments

  1. John G Avery
    Report Abuse
    John G Avery - September 18, 2014 4:21 am
    Thanks for the post Richard. l like your views and you have good resources to deal with to get the largest benefit of it. I found the Dental Clinic In hungary are also great to deal with its patients and provide great treatment.
  2. Rose Pettaway
    Report Abuse
    Rose Pettaway - September 16, 2014 8:23 am
    Education gives the youngsters trust in themselves to learn and apply their innovative musings in a positive and solid exercises. Education alters their reasoning and essay paper writing company reviews grooms them in a sensible youth.
  3. Rose Pettaway
    Report Abuse
    Rose Pettaway - September 16, 2014 2:52 am
    The essay writing service is a grantee of a decent and quality work for the understudy that is a surety of decent evaluations. They can believe to pay people to write your essays with their home works, exploration papers and assignments.
  4. Seriously Now
    Report Abuse
    Seriously Now - April 08, 2013 6:26 am
    The problem with the idea is that those so stupid to injure themselves in stupid ways (watch any episode of AFHV) think they are "entitled to compensation" as the TV legal ads put it.
  5. Mentat
    Report Abuse
    Mentat - April 07, 2013 7:25 pm
    I think the point of this article is that empathy and sincerity are more likely to prevent a frivolous lawsuit than taking the approach of making the irresponsible party feel stupid. We have a plethora of unscrupulous lawyers willing to take such cases. Even an unsuccessful lawsuit costs the defendant time, money, and stress. All that grief might be avoided by taking a sympathetic approach, as difficult as it may be.
  6. Monteee
    Report Abuse
    Monteee - April 07, 2013 1:17 pm
    It's getting so bad that many people don't even know what the word "apologize" means. They literally cannot use it in a sentence correctly. As they can't/won't admit to any wrong doing, they lack the words to express it.
  7. Monteee
    Report Abuse
    Monteee - April 07, 2013 10:40 am
    " I am really sorry that you got hurt, but the fact is that you used the ladder upside down. You caused your own injury."

    Works for me!
  8. FUBAR
    Report Abuse
    FUBAR - April 07, 2013 10:39 am
    Remember SN, we have become a society of taken NO responsibility for our own actions. As a society we love to place blame on others and we give kids built in excuses for bad actions by telling them they all have ADD, ADHD, etc...Many people in our society feel they should be rewarded monetarily for their own stupidity. For being the "smartest" animal on earth we are really quite stupid.

    And I agree with your post.
  9. Seriously Now
    Report Abuse
    Seriously Now - April 07, 2013 8:40 am
    What? "People do stupid things..most people ...are willing to make allowances, but only if goodwill and sincerity are evident at the outset. " So you need to say, "I'm sincerely sorry you are so friggin stupid that you stuck you hand in a running snow-blower to free up a stuck blade." "I'm sincerely sorry you are so friggin stupid you didn't buckle up and were ejected through your windshield." Some times the truth hurts.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Search local business directory

Hint: Enter a keyword that you are looking for like tires, pizza or doctors or browse the full business directory.

Follow The La Crosse Tribune

Latest Local Offers

Today's Question


Which party will win the White House in 2016?

View Results

Featured Businesses



Sign Up for Our Email Lists

Breaking News, News Update and Sports Update Headlines. Delivered at 11a.m. daily.

Sign up for Events, Contests and Promotions

Business report, local Business news. Delivered once per month.

New employment opportunities in the region.

Local homes for sale.

Cars, Trucks, Vans, SUVs, Motorcycles, ATVs, Boats, RV's & more