Try 1 month for 99¢

As cleanup of a derailment south of Brownsville, Minn., continued for a third day, questions remained about whether the Canadian Pacific freight train was hauling crude oil, ethanol or other dangerous materials.

The 68-car train was en route from St. Paul, Minn., to Kansas City when 15 cars left the tracks Tuesday night, sending six tank cars and about 850 gallons of vegetable oil into the Mississippi River.

Three of the 15 cars that left the tracks were carrying sodium chlorate, a strong oxidizing agent that poses significant health and safety issues when being loaded and unloaded, according to the Environmental Protection Agency.

A small amount of the material spilled, though there was not what the EPA calls a “critical breach” and no sodium chlorate has been detected in the river, according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

Canadian Pacific has not provided a list of what other cargo the train was hauling.

Spokesman Andy Cummings said Friday that other products on board included scrap metal, malt and flour but cited “security reasons” for not disclosing any other dangerous goods that may have been present.

Cummings said CP shares details of hazardous materials “confidentially” with first responders.

A spokeswoman for the EPA said she did not know whether the railroad had provided a manifest to the agency, which is one of several monitoring the cleanup. Phillippa Cannon referred questions about the train contents to the railroad.

A Federal Railroad Administration spokesman would only say that the incident is under investigation.

Railroads have come under increased scrutiny in recent years with the rapid growth of crude oil shipments. A CP train carrying crude oil derailed Nov. 8 in Watertown, Wis., one day after a BNSF train derailed near Alma, Wis., spilling up to 20,000 gallons of ethanol into the Mississippi River. It was the 10th North American derailment of 2015 involving oil or ethanol, according to the McClatchy news service.

According to the latest available reports, about nine trains per week run on the CP line through Houston and La Crosse counties, carrying more than a million gallons of crude. CP reported less than one train per week on the line where Tuesday’s derailment occurred.

Citizens Acting for Rail Safety said that while Tuesday’s derailment did not result in a major release of hazardous material, it “brings to light the potential for serious accidents that can cause disastrous consequences to our communities and environment.” The rail safety group noted that hazardous materials besides oil and ethanol traverse the area daily.

Cummings said CP is required by law to accept all shipments that meet federal standards and the railroad carries a wide variety of goods, including hazardous materials.

“We take our responsibility for safe handling of these materials very seriously,” he said. “Railroads are the safest way to move goods over land. When an incident does occur, we have personnel on staff with the training and expertise to respond to an incident involving any product that we handle.”

Cleanup continues

Cleanup was expected to continue into the weekend as workers unloaded the overturned tankers and awaited a specialty contractor to handle the sodium chlorate.

The railroad reopened the line running south from La Crescent into Iowa around 4:30 a.m. Thursday, a little more than 30 hours after the derailment.

Railroad contractors believed Thursday they had contained the leaking oil and unloaded three tankers. They planned to unload the remaining three Friday. Barriers were placed in the river to contain any oil that made it into the river.

Though it’s not considered a hazardous material, vegetable oil can coat aquatic animals and prevent them from absorbing oxygen, said Sabrina Chandler, refuge manager for the Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife and Fish Refuge.

Chandler said no visible impacts to wildlife had been detected as of Friday.

Three 55-gallon drums of spilled sodium chlorate were recovered from the site. According to the EPA, the railroad is awaiting a contractor from Manitoba, Canada, to unload the remaining cars with specialized equipment to prevent the release of dust.

Subscribe to Daily Headlines

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

(8) comments


True security would require that they reveal the hazardous materials.

Alan Muller


Alan Muller

First, lets thank the CARS people for staying on top of this issue.

The secrecy about this, the refusal to fully disclose what was in the cars that derailed, is unacceptable. It's hard to be sure of course, about what we don't know the details of. But I get the impression that the railroads basically don't want the public to be aware of how much dangerous stuff is passing through out communities, through wetlands and along river banks....

Sodium chlorate is a strong oxidizer. If it came in contact with some other types of material the consequences might be spectacular and not in a good way.

This, of course, does not mean that hazardous materials should never move by rail. It may often be, at least potentially, the safest method. But more attention to safety is needed.


So Ruth what would you do different in your life if you KNEW a train carrying hazardous material was headed your way? Would you cower in the basement until it passed through your part of town? Give me a break. Railroads shouldn't have to announce what hazmat is on each train. If you did some research on the placards you would get the info you seek.


Why is it when a train tips over everyone attacks the railroad.But not one person ever says anything about what this world would do without the rails hauling these products.These chemicals affect everything this world does because if not the railroad hauling these chemical no plastic products would be produce,most foods wouldn't last a week and most people wouldn't be able to drive to work because no oil would be moving.When these accidents happen it sucks but until someone comes up with a tranporting machine we see in the star war movie these products have to delivered to the manufacturer some how correct?? If you don't want to believe that shut the rails down for a week and see what happens.I myself would love to see the world chemical free and live off the grid as they say but the truth is most of us can't. I also believe the rails are the most safe and economical way of hauling the products we need to live this life of luxury.Can't have your cake and eat it to as they say :)


You can have your cake and eat it too, with better planning and engineering. With proper maintenance and slower speeds in populated areas. Or by routing the trains away from population centers. No need to burn human beings alive for our cake....

Canada Oil Train Explosion Lac Megantic Full HD


you are correct agreed but no one has figured that out so for now we have to live with it

Ruth Sundaram

So If I am prevented from absorbing oxygen (remember all the ducks,geese,pelicans etc. covered in oil) would I say that this is not a hazardous material to me? We need to reconsider what we say is hazardous. Anything hazardous to wildlife eventually will be hazardous to all of us. We prepare for snowstorms by 1st having fair warning that a storm is coming...our railroad "storms" are never on our radar because they are so dangerous we are not willing to "see" what is coming. Are we any more secure by telling us that for security reasons we shall not know what storm is approaching?

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Thanks for reading. Subscribe or log in to continue.