Try 1 month for 99¢

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources is asking judges to dismiss a lawsuit challenging the agency’s authority to overrule another judge’s findings regarding a controversial Monroe County frac sand processing facility.

Last month Clean Wisconsin and the Ho-Chunk Nation filed suits in Monroe and Dane county courts claiming DNR Secretary Dan Meyer overstepped his authority when he agreed to review an administrative law judge’s ruling that had invalidated a permit issued to Meteor Timber for the proposed $75 million processing and loading facility.

In court briefs filed Monday on behalf of the DNR, attorneys from the Wisconsin Department of Justice argue that the courts have no standing to review Meyer’s decision because it is not final.

Administrative law Judge Eric Defort ruled in May that the DNR didn’t have information required by state law when it issued a permit allowing Meteor to fill 16.25 acres of wetlands near Millston. His decision to reverse the permit followed a five-day hearing during which several former DNR employees said the agency granted the permit in spite of its own staff findings and a list of unanswered questions.

Acting on a request from the Georgia-based investment company, Meyer later appointed staff attorney Mark Herman to review Defort’s ruling.

State attorneys argue that Meyer’s decision to review Defort’s ruling is not final because it doesn’t affect anyone’s rights.

“The substantial rights of the parties are undetermined until the secretarial review is complete and a final decision is rendered,” the brief states. “At the end of the secretarial review, DNR will issue a final decision and either affirm the ALJ’s decision to deny the wetland permits or it will reverse the ALJ’s decision and issue the permits.”

Allowing “piecemeal, successive reviews” would result in multiple appeals, create the potential for inconsistent judicial decisions and make the process more complicated, according to the state’s brief.

The state also says neither Clean Wisconsin nor the Ho-Chunk Nation have standing to sue because they have not demonstrated actual harm.

Clean Wisconsin staff attorney Evan Feinaur said, “We expected this motion and we’re confident in the merits of our case.”

Tressie Kamp, staff attorney for Midwest Environmental Advocates, which is representing the Ho-Chunk, declined to comment on the motion to dismiss.

The DOJ has asked the courts to consolidate the cases before a Monroe County judge. Feinauer said Clean Wisconsin will seek to have the cases consolidated in Dane County, which MEA does not oppose.

“Our client’s claims have strength and merit regardless of venue,” Kamp said.Millston.

Subscribe to Daily Headlines

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Chris Hubbuch can be reached at 608-791-8217. Follow him on Twitter @chrishubbuch.



Rhymes with Lubbock. La Crosse Tribune reporter and data geek. Covers energy, transportation and the environment, among other things.

(5) comments


This headline appeared in the Urban Milwaukee publication of March 27, 2018, "GOP 'S Favorite Sand Mine Company" "For the second time in as many months, the GOP -controlled Assembly has approved a break for a proposed frac sand mining operation whose owners contributed $ 12,000 to the state Republican Party last year. In addition, attorneys for Weld Riley , an Eau Claire law firm that represents Meteor, contributed about $31,400 to legislative and statewide canditates, including $20,300 to Walker himself between January 2010 and June 2017. John Behling, a Wild Riley attorney is also a Walker appointee to the University of Wisconsin Board of Regents." Spread the word to all the citizens of the following counties-- Monroe, Jackson, Buffalo, Dunn and other areas whose lives are being traumatized by the sand mine companies. It certainly does not make sense to cast your vote this fall for a Governor and the rest of his followers who could care less about the CITIZENS WHO VOTED FOR THEM in the past . Do you really understand what's going here.


I, too, am tired of watching the GOP cater to the rich allowing them to trash our state with no respect for us that actually LIVE HERE.


The RDNR is actively working against the interests of the people of the state and is undermining the quality of the environment. They are continually siding with corporate interests to the detriment of the citizens and taxpayers. The republicans are destroying the state for short-term profits. This is disgusting.


I wonder if Buggs is sick of it.


The Wisconsin DNR used to be a highly recognized department. Since Scooter they have become one of the laughing stock agencies in Wisconsin. Many highly regarded scientists and biologists have left or been pushed out.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Thanks for reading. Subscribe or log in to continue.