{{featured_button_text}}
Richard Kyte

Richard Kyte is the director of the D.B. Reinhart Institute for Ethics in Leadership at Viterbo University. He also is a member of the Tribune's editorial board.

A committee of the La Crosse Common Council has proposed a sign ordinance that would regulate various features of signs, such as size, placement, brightness, height and so on. Many residents favor the sign proposal; many businesses oppose it. I would think it would be the other way around.

Sometimes the way we define a controversy determines our response to it. If we think of an issue in terms of quality of life vs. economics, then we will think of it as residents vs. business. But in La Crosse, our economy is inextricably linked with quality of life. So the question for the Common Council is simple: What kinds of signs will enhance our local economy?

The most attention-grabbing signs are not always the best for business. A couple of weeks ago I was driving through a small town in northern Minnesota and noticed a sign on the side of a café/gas station. It read: “Eat here. Get gas and worms.” I’m sure the sign attracted lots of attention; I’m not so sure it attracted many customers. At any rate, I did not stop. I already had gas and worms.

If you are a La Crosse resident you probably don’t pay much attention to the number, variety and placement of signs because they are so familiar. It’s like the clutter in our living rooms that goes unnoticed until a visitor drops in.

Most people like their own clutter but dislike the clutter of others.

Our own clutter is comfortable; it’s the natural byproduct of activity. Sometimes, of course, it gets to be too much. When you spend more time looking for a pen than writing, it’s time to clean the desk.

When I see another person’s clutter, I immediately think: “He sure is lazy.” When I survey my own clutter, I think: “I sure am busy.”

Too many signs arranged haphazardly will make a city appear cluttered. But a city without signs is like a desk without papers: there’s nothing going on there.

Ever notice that bedroom communities have very few signs? Zzzzzz.

You have free articles remaining.

Become a Member

Register for more free articles.
Stay logged in to skip the surveys.

Out-of-towners form a lasting impression of our city within the first 15 minutes of their visit. What they perceive is not so much particular buildings or features but rather what the German philosopher Gernot Böhme termed “atmosphere.” People get a general mood or impression of a place first; later, when they’ve become accustomed to the area, their perception tends to become more focused and selective.

Signs are the means by which we find our way around. One function of signs is to convey specific information, usually by labeling, reminding or directing. Another function of signs is to complement the built and natural environment by creating a positive atmosphere, that is, to make the city inviting and attractive, especially for visitors.  

A city that conducts business strictly among residents only has to worry about the first function of signs; a city that relies on attracting outsiders, whether they be tourists, shoppers, students or conferencegoers, must be concerned also — and primarily — with the ways signs contribute to the atmosphere of the city.

There are places where signs create an intentional atmosphere-where they are meant to draw attention to themselves —places like Las Vegas or Times Square in Manhattan. But La Crosse is not such a place. I’ve never heard a tourist say, “You have such attractive signs here!”

Visitors are generally impressed with La Crosse: they love the historic downtown, they love the river, they love the bluffs. But before they see any of those things, they have to travel through the cluttered corridors that serve as entryways into the city. And even though we residents may feel perfectly comfortable with them, they don’t make a good first impression.     

The sign ordinance proposal would establish guidelines to ensure that signs complement rather than detract from their natural surroundings. It is a fairly simple either-or proposition. If we care about bringing in business from visitors, we clean up our clutter. If we don’t care about that, we leave it the way it is. After all, once you live here a while, you don’t even notice it.


The Ethical Life is a series of reflections on the ways ethical thinking influences our actions, emotions and relationships. Richard Kyte is the director of the D.B. Reinhart Institute for Ethics in Leadership at Viterbo University.

0
0
0
0
0

(6) comments

colnzgprnts

The author fails to consider the issue of signage in terms of basic American principles. Signs are a means of expression; as Americans we have cherished our rights of free speech.Sign ordinances limit free speech.

Mr Kyle may not be of the opinion that a sign on a given restaurant is effective, but he is not the person who put money and time into the restaurant. Who is he to say he knows more and is better able to make a decision about what message is on the sign than is the owner of the business - he is in effect saying that he or some bureaucrat should decide the message in terms of content, size and placement. He is advocating collectivism which is dangerous in a free society.

If Mr Kyle and bureaucrats can dictate to a business owner what signs the owner of the business can display, then what is to stop Mr Kyle and the bureaucrats from dictating the color of the store and the location of the store, who is hired and who is fired and every detail of the business.

Kyle couches the concepts he advocates as ethics but what he is really advocating is tyranny - a new phenomena that is gaining ground in what was once a great nation and is now sliding into something more like like a benevolent dictatorship than the republic our founding fathers envisioned.

Buggs Raplin

Mack, couldn't agree more on all those G/L and F/S billboards.

Mack

I DO notice that so many of the signs are for our clinics and hospitals. They should both be embarrassed that they are spending our healthcare dollars in this manner rather than on actually improving healthcare. The non-stop drug commercials on TV or in the same wasteful category. Medicine for PROFIT is an embarrassment and there are better models from more advanced countries. Greed in Medicine is going to take us down the same path our financial institutions took us down just a couple of years ago.

got2hunt

I believe the 5 Man Electrical Band said it all in a song with a chorus that went like this;

"Signs, Signs, Everywhere there are Signs
Blocking out the scenery, Breaking my mind
Do this! Don't do that! Can't you read the signs"

JanC

I concur with Mr. Kyte: the beauty of La Crosse is an absolute draw to visitors and business. Control of all signage is paramount to maintaining the ambience of our area. There are a plethora of studies proving that strict control of signage is a positive aspect of any community. We need to strongly support the proposed Ordinance of the City's Signage Committee.

57

Well rich I hate the signs but they are there and should stay.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.