Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
DNR study finds irrigation responsible for draining lakes

DNR study finds irrigation responsible for draining lakes


The state Department of Natural Resources says farm irrigation is to blame for lower water levels on lakes in central Wisconsin.

The findings are the result of a three-year study to evaluate the impact of large wells on three lakes in Waushara County that was mandated by a 2017 law passed by Republican legislators that also loosened regulation of high-capacity wells.

The DNR is recommending creation of a water use district to manage water use in the region and is accepting public comments on the draft report and recommendations released Tuesday. The agency will hold an online public hearing April 28 to discuss the findings.

Central Sands study area

The Central Sands Lakes Study looked at water levels on Pleasant, Long and Plainfield lakes and found high-capacity wells used for agriculture significantly reduced water levels on two lakes — Long and Plainfield — and is close to impacting the third.

According to the study, groundwater withdrawals reduce lake levels by as much as 3 feet, affecting recreation, fish, plants and water chemistry on Long Lake and a federally endangered plant on Plainfield, which does not support a fish population.

The study found irrigation has lowered Pleasant Lake by up to 6 inches, which is not considered a significant reduction. But it is within 2.5 inches of significant impact.

“Based on current irrigation it is not impacted,” said Adam Freihoefer, the DNR’s section chief for water use. “If there’s new high-cap wells that come into the system — it’s close to becoming (impacted).”

More than 95% of groundwater withdrawals in the area are connected to agriculture.

The Biden administration's work to sell its more than $2 trillion infrastructure plan is underway and it's facing opposition from within its own party.Sen. Joe Manchin told a West Virginia radio host Monday that he won't support the plan if the corporate tax rate is raised from 21 to 28 percent as proposed. He said several of his Democratic colleagues agree with him.The plan won't pass the Senate without the support of every Democratic senator, but the White House says it isn't concerned."Some will believe that the package we proposed is too small. Some will believe it's too big. And we're happy to have discussions with members who have both points of view," said White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki. "We're hopeful that others will come forward with ideas that are as bold and innovative and will help do the same type of work for American workers in our economy."GOP leader Mitch McConnell has already said the plan won't get a single Republican vote, but the administration says it remains hopeful for a bipartisan deal.Already, the five cabinet members tasked with outreach have had conversations with 56 lawmakers split evenly among Democrats and Republicans.The president plans to invite lawmakers from both parties to the Oval Office once they return from recess. 

Prior to the 1960s, the report says, there were about 110 wells that could draw at least 100,000 gallons of water per day in the Central Sands, a 1.75-million acre area east of the Wisconsin River with deep sand and gravel deposits. Today there are about 3,100, each drawing an average of 1.4 million gallons per day.

The DNR says the lakes are affected not by any single well but by the collective impact, a finding in line with previous Central Sands research, and concludes that site-specific management approaches are unlikely to work.

Instead, the report recommends a comprehensive regional strategy.

“You have to look at the system collectively,” Freihoefer said. “You have to look at the resources and the pumping — as one larger system.”

According to the report, a water district could balance conservation and economic objectives through the use of practices such as metering, voluntary water use reductions, incentives, withdrawal limits, land retirement and more efficient irrigation practices.

In developing its recommendations, Freihoefer said researchers looked at how other states — including Kansas, Nebraska, Michigan and Florida — manage water resources.

“We’re not trying to come up with something that’s new or novel,” he said. “We’re trying to find something that would work based on what’s worked in other places.”

The DNR last year said it would again consider the impact on lakes and streams before granting permits for high-capacity wells, reversing a four-year policy adopted under former Gov. Scott Walker.

The reversal came after Attorney General Josh Kaul reversed the guidance of his Republican predecessor regarding an issue under consideration by the state Supreme Court.

The DNR is recommending creation of a water use district to manage the resource in central Wisconsin.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News