First, they came for the unemployment rate, and we brushed it off as tinfoil-hat nonsense.

Then they came for crowd sizes, and we laughed at the absurdity.

The next victim was the deficit, which they said was shrinking even as we saw it rising; also climate data, which they denigrated, doctored or disappeared without a trace. But we said, eh, they always do that, no big deal.

Catherine Rampell mug

Catherine Rampell

They purged the data-crunchers who tabulate crop prices and other agricultural statistics, and we ignored it because we weren’t farmers. They even came for the yield curve, which they said hadn’t inverted when it had, but also that even if it did invert, the inversion would mean the opposite of what everyone knows it means.

Now, they’ve come for the weather forecast. And if earlier episodes in President Trump’s war on statistics threatened livelihoods, this one threatens lives.

For a week, Trump obsessively insisted that his errant tweet about Hurricane Dorian’s threat to Alabama was correct. The episode included a moment so ridiculous it would have been too broad even for the HBO comedy series “Veep:” Last Wednesday, Trump showed a hurricane map that had obviously been doctored with a Sharpie.

It was funny, telegenic, easy to grasp. So, understandably, Sharpiegate got news coverage up the wazoo. The more ominous developments in this saga, however, got significantly less attention. They happened the previous Sunday, when the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration sent a secret agencywide directive warning its scientists not to contradict the president, and then the subsequent Friday, when NOAA released an unsigned statement backing Trump’s false forecast and disparaging its own scientists. It was reportedly sent after the commerce secretary threatened firings. Sure, Trump’s attacks on objective statistics, scientists or really any independent source of accountability are nothing new. On the contrary, such attacks have become ubiquitous. Anyone who dares to produce or even accurately report on politically inconvenient metrics is allegedly participating in a vast anti-Trump conspiracy or is somehow rooting for America to fail.

You have free articles remaining.

Become a Member

Register for more free articles.
Stay logged in to skip the surveys.

And, at this point, media corrections of Trump’s false claims about stock performance, or air purity, or the strength of the manufacturing sector, can feel tedious, pedantic and exhausting. Trump’s just being Trump, pundits scold. We should all move on to “real” concerns rather than these distractions from whatever other horrible (or, depending on your viewpoint, wonderful) things the administration is doing. But these are real concerns. Trump’s attempted manipulations of official metrics — and the aspersions he casts upon metrics he cannot manipulate — degrade our democracy, economy and public safety. Distrust in official data is deadly to voters’ ability to evaluate public policies, as well as the records of the officials crafting or overseeing those policies.

This numerical nihilism likewise wears on companies’ and households’ abilities to make informed and economically efficient decisions, something Trump’s billionaire Cabinet should appreciate.

And as illustrated by the administration’s insistence that even the weather report is fake, the erosion of trust in government data can also kill people.

The director of the National Weather Service gave a brave speech on Monday — at an annual meteorological meeting in Alabama, of all places. He noted that shortly after Trump’s initial Alabama hurricane tweet, the National Weather Service’s Birmingham office noticed its “phones and social media” light up with questions about Dorian. Without actually knowing what had triggered these worried inquiries, it tweeted to assure the public that “Alabama will NOT see any impacts from #Dorian.”

“They did that with one thing in mind: public safety,” NWS Director Louis Uccellini said, defending the employees his superiors had attacked. “The Birmingham office did this to stop panic.”

After all, just as there are costs to failing to alert people about dangerous weather, so, too, are there costs to encouraging people to freak out about dangerous weather that doesn’t exist. For the National Weather Service, long-term credibility matters: If people come to believe the government hypes or even invents the risk of natural disaster, they might ignore those warnings next time there actually is significant risk of natural disaster.

This problem is not theoretical. It happened in Joplin, Missouri, in 2011, when 158 people died from a powerful tornado despite National Weather Service warnings. A subsequent NOAA report found that the perceived frequency of tornado warning sirens had caused people to become “desensitized or complacent” and “not take protective action” until it was too late.

Just as we don’t want Americans to become “desensitized or complacent” about the risk of deadly weather, neither should we allow ourselves to become “desensitized or complacent” about the risk this president presents to one of our country’s most precious assets: reliable, trustworthy, nonpartisan public data.

Be the first to know - Sign up for Breaking News

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Washington Post columnist Catherine Rampell can be reached at crampell@washpost.com.


(10) comments


What a powerful, commendable column. It is so easy to laugh off something like Sharpie-gate as just another silly misstep by our idiot president. His persistent degrading of the vital work done by our government agencies, and his attacks on science and the scientific method are not at all funny. They are extremely dangerous and threatening to the well-being of all of us. If this loon is re-elected, we are going to be in free fall as a democracy, a nation and an economic engine.

Rick Czeczok

No comment, this writer is not worth my time.....


Right RickyBoy. You can not be bothered by a thoughtful well informed columnist. Now get back to Hannity and the other liars on Fox.


The Comrade continues to support the Tribune by reading the articles and providing clicks for advertisers. And he continues to insist that the paper is failing, though his daily viewing is paying to keep the lights on and the presses rolling.


mr. R. comrade zerokok needs to take one day at a time,since time is not on your side.

Think about it :old timer.


Neither is telling us what you taught apparently...


Trump is not concerned with facts or truth. All he cares about is his his ego. His apologists on here will defend this behavior or brush it off as pure conjecture or supposition (Dmoney), but it is dangerous. There are certain things which are true. Pretending they are not true puts everyone at risk. It continues to amaze me that an entire political party acts as if reality does not exist. All that matters to them is maintaining power. I am disgusted beyond belief with the Republican Party. Whether it is the garbage that passed for democracy in North Carolina yesterday (9/11), or the "extraordinary session" in Wisconsin to limit the power of a Democratic Governor. Trump is just one more example of a party that has no moral compass. What a disgrace they are.


When trump"s lips are moving ....he is lying. When Trump-Humper"s lips are moving....they are lying. .....crank,newts,climatesdope,wiz,zerokok...all liars -all the time. That is a fact . That is also a real fact and an honest ,truthful, real fact.


Sharpie-gate is just another example of how Trump twists everything to benefit himself, rather than allowing government to work for the people. He's dangerous and his supporters are pathetic.


welcome to Trumpy world. Reality is what you make it, in this case what Trumpy wants it to be. Double down on the lies, pressure people to agree with you or they might lose their jobs. Keep repeating the lies hoping some how they are accepted as true. Just the type of leader we need. And again the fanatical right wingers will rationalize it away.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.