Jonathan Bernstein: Amy Klobuchar stood out on debate stage

Jonathan Bernstein: Amy Klobuchar stood out on debate stage

  • 8

The obvious headline out of the Democratic debate Tuesday was simple: The candidates, by spending the first hour attacking her, confirmed that they agreed with the polls that Elizabeth Warren is now the most likely nominee.

The result, by the first commercial break, was a massive edge for Warren in time holding the stage; she spoke for more than twice as long as any other candidate over the opening hour. I’m always reluctant to guess how viewers responded, but she seemed to at least hold her own. There was certainly no obvious breakdown.

That said, as usual, the leading candidates had the least at stake. Warren, Joe Biden, Bernie Sanders and a few others have already qualified for the next debate in November and aren’t starved for resources.

Jonathan Bernstein mug

Jonathan Bernstein

While any nationally televised appearance can help or hurt, we’re still at the point where most voters aren’t paying much attention, and those who are — the party actors intensely involved in candidate selection — will less likely be swayed by either a great moment or a horrible one.

The candidates with the most on the line continue to be those trailing in the polls but, if they could only get a sudden surge, would be perfectly plausible nominees. That’s true for Kamala Harris, Cory Booker and perhaps Pete Buttigieg, although he’s probably doing better than that make-or-break level.

It’s especially true for Amy Klobuchar, Beto O’Rourke and Julian Castro, all of whom are in danger of failing to qualify for the November rematch. Remember, it’s not just the debates themselves; other events, such as last week’s CNN forum, are using the qualifiers for their invitation list, too.

Of the three on the bubble, O’Rourke seems to me, at least, to be flailing. Castro had some good moments, especially on police violence, but they came relatively deep into the CNN-New York Times debate. He didn’t seem to do enough to undo the damage from attacking Biden in the September contest.

Klobuchar probably had her strongest debate. She remains the only candidate to employ pre-packaged zingers to add some humor to the mix, something several others really lack. And this time, she was more aggressive, including one sustained attack on Warren. She managed to rank third in speaking time overall, difficult to achieve since the highest-ranked candidates, based on polls, typically get more time.

Will it be enough to keep her candidacy alive? Klobuchar desperately needs national media time, and it’s not clear that any of her strong moments were likely to be included in TV reports. She was fine (as far as I could tell), but there were other exchanges that may have been more dramatic. Nor were her prepared bits funny enough, or even groan-worthy enough, to necessarily make the cut.

Candidates need to reach 3% in four different horse-race polls to qualify for the November debate. Klobuchar has been getting lots of 2% results. So she doesn’t need much … but she does need something.

Harris, Booker and Buttigieg all had nice moments. Nothing that seemed likely to produce a spike in the polls, but perhaps enough to keep fundraising going. They’ll each have a somewhat larger share of the time in the next, smaller debate.

So, sure, the headlines should go to Warren and her newly recognized front-runner status. But the big question coming in was about the candidates who are struggling. The question going out is really whether Amy Klobuchar gets rewarded with a media-fueled bounce or not.

Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering politics and policy.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

When a fresh news poll finds that a majority of Republicans believe that Donald Trump is a better president than Abraham Lincoln was, what's an old-school, never-Trump Republican to do? For Rick Wilson, it's more of the same, with even more fire and fury - talking on television, and writing another book. The new one, "Running Against the Devil," is out next month, and in it, the veteran GOP ...

"There is no character, howsoever good and fine, but it can be destroyed by ridicule, howsoever poor and witless." - Mark Twain When President Donald Trump used his Twitter feed to intimidate the former ambassador to Ukraine while she was testifying before the House Intelligence Committee, his malign intent was more obvious than his rhetorical strategy. "Everywhere Marie Yovanovitch went ...

Now that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has charged her colleagues with the tasks of drafting and approving articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump - and assuming the House votes to impeach - our focus should shift to a discussion of what the Senate proceedings are going to look like. If the Senate conducts a trial - an actual search for the truth that involves a serious reckoning ...

From Elizabeth Warren to Tulsi Gabbard, the Democratic presidential candidates have come out strong for breaking up big tech. It has become a central focus of Warren's campaign, which has caused business leaders like Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg to voice concern, and the fight over big tech within the Democratic Party presidential primaries has bled into the courts. In all of this, Andrew Yang ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News