
“In American politics, winning isn’t winning unless the other side is losing, and losing badly. This shouldn’t be. And it doesn’t have to be.” — U.S. Reps. Mike Gallagher, Republican from Green Bay, and Chrissy Houlahan, Democrat from Pennsylvania, in their forward to the book: “The Politics Industry: How Political Innovation Can Break Partisan Gridlock and Save Our Democracy.”
The problem in American politics isn’t that the other side is losing.
The problem is that the voters are losing. Solution-based legislation is losing. Good governance is losing. Democracy is losing. Who is winning? Special-interest groups that fund the extremes and count on the gridlock of status quo to paralyze responsible governance.
In their book, “The Politics Industry,” Katherine M. Gehl and Michael E. Porter argue that – for the sake of true democracy – it’s time for voters to change the rules.
Thankfully, two state senators – Republican Dale Kooyenga and Democrat Jeff Smith — and two state representatives — Democrat Daniel Reimer and Republican Tony Kurtz — circulated a bill last month to advance a change of rules for federal elections in Wisconsin — and we fully support it.
The two-step concept calls for single-ballot primaries followed by general elections that provide an instant runoff to assure the winner actually has a majority. One of the key causes of gridlock is the politically run primary system of elections.
As we’ve seen too often in Wisconsin, legislators are often punished by their own party for supporting solution-based, bipartisan initiatives. That means the political parties and special interests will keep legislators in line with the threat of a political opponent from the political extreme of the party. Somehow, they have turned “primaried” into a verb. That may serve party leadership, but it clearly doesn’t serve voters who want bipartisan solutions.
As political science emeritus Joe Heim of the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse has long argued, it reduces true competition for votes and puts the parties in control. How do we change the rules and break the party grip? The proposed legislation calls for Final Five voting: The combination of top-five primaries and Ranked Choice Voting in general elections.
Here’s how the plan would work:
Instead of voting for one party or the other in the primary, you would vote in a single-ballot primary. The top five vote-getters would proceed to the general election. Instead of one finalist per party, for example, that final five could include two Republicans, two Democrats and one independent — meaning more competition for votes.
In the general election, voters would rank those candidates one through five under a process called Ranked Choice Voting.
If the top vote-getter receives more than 50 percent as the Number 1 preference, that person is elected.
But if no candidate receives a majority as the first preference, the person who comes in fifth is thrown out of the pool under Ranked Choice Voting. The ballots that listed the eliminated candidate as the top choice are redistributed counting the second preference.
Those second-place votes will help determine the person elected from the remaining four candidates — and it’s certainly possible that the person in third place among top-preference votes would receive enough votes as second choice to leap to the top as election winner.
If enacted, this would change the rules for electing those running for federal office from Wisconsin — for Congress, for instance.
Part of the appeal would be for candidates to run a positive campaign for voter support instead of attacking opponents.
We’re sick of hired guns from other parts of the country coming here to run nasty campaigns when they wouldn’t know the Mississippi River from Coon Creek. The voting process has been enacted in Alaska and is being considered in other states, including Wisconsin.
The initiative has the support of LeaderEthics-Wisconsin.
“We believe this is a serious effort, designed to curtail some of the hyper-partisanship we are seeing in politics today,” executive director Lee Rasch said. “We are encouraged that the legislation has bipartisan sponsorship.” The proposal does not tackle the troublesome influence of money in political campaigns, but as Rasch says, this initiative is a good first step toward returning control to voters.
Democracy Found, a Wisconsin-based initiative committed to revitalizing democracy, is promoting the legislation. You can learn more at www.democracyfound.org.
IN PHOTOS: Voting Day in La Crosse
Voting Day

Voters exit the polling place for ward 13, 15, 17, and 18 Tuesday at the Coulee Recovery Center.
Voting Day

Three-year-old Montgomery Bolanos waits for his mother, Karina Bolanos, as she votes at the Coulee Recovery Center.
Voting Day

Voters fill out their ballots Tuesday at the Coulee Recovery Center.
Voting Day

Polling place workers Kay Hatlestad, left, and Karen Martin process absentee ballots at the Coulee Recovery Center.
Voting Day

Margret Wood processes absentee ballots Tuesday at the Coulee Recovery Center. The polling place for wards 13, 15, 17, and 18 had an estimated 1000 absentee ballots submitted.
Voting Day

Liam Moran, left, and Melinda Byerly process absentee ballots Tuesday at the polling place at Mitchel Hall on the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse campus.
Voting Day

Voters wait to submit their ballots at the polling place at University of Wisconsin La Crosse’s Mitchel Hall.
Voting Day

Voters fill out their ballots Tuesday at the polling place for wards 8 and 11 at Mitchel Hall on the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse campus.
Voting Day

Melinda Byerly processes absentee ballots at the polling place at Mitchel Hall on the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse campus.
Voting Day

A voter submits a ballot Tuesday at University of Wisconsin La Crosse’s Mitchel Hall as others fill theirs out.
Voting Day

Angie Bernstein, a volunteer from Viroqua with Election Defenders, offers personal protective equipment and general help to voters Tuesday outside of the Coulee Recovery Center.
Voting Day

Jeremy Kimpel shows his ID Tuesday before voting Tuesday at the Coulee Recovery Center in La Crosse.
Voting Day

Poll worker Kathy Allen, left, hands voter, Jen Neuhaus, her ballot Tuesday at the Coulee Recovery Center.
Voting Day

Second time voter Cydney Livingston, left, checks her ballot as her friend and first time voter Alana Bouquet watches on at the polling place at the Coulee Recovery Center.